Joe Strauss of the St. Louis Dispatch believes that it is almost a given that Cardinals pitcher Anthony Reyes will be dealt soon.

Of the fact that Reyes, who was once considered one of the game’s top pitching prospects, was once again demoted to the minors last week, Strauss writes, “This year, however, the club appears firmer than ever in its stance: If Reyes enjoys success as a major-league pitcher it will likely occur elsewhere.”

Reyes’ most recent demotion represents the team’s use of his final option, meaning that if the club demotes him again next season, he’ll have to pass through waivers first.  That means, of course, that if St. Louis feels they have done all they can with Reyes, now may be the last chance they have to get something decent in return via trade.   And it appears that pitching coach Dave Duncan is, in fact, ready to give up on Reyes.  As Strauss writes, “Reyes is most comfortable throwing a four-seam fastball while pitching up and away from contact. It is no secret Duncan prefers a two-seam approach, pitching down with a desire for ground balls early in counts.”

General manager John Mozeliak insists that he is not ready to dump Reyes, though, saying, “We have no interest in giving Anthony Reyes away.”  Mozeliak is apparently asking for a top prospect plus another prospect in an attempt to fleece.  But it seems obvious that the Cards are at the end of their rope with Reyes, so any team that offers up a decent package for the pitcher deserves to get fleeced.  In my opinion, Reyes represents a very good “buy low” opportunity for a team that can afford to be patient with him. 

Filed under: St. Louis Cardinals